How many budget categories do you really need?

With budgets ranging from a handful of categories to dozens, here's how to pinpoint how many budget categories you really need
By Meagan Faryna
•
20 September 2024
Share:
How many budget categories

You stare at your budget spreadsheet, wondering if you've gone overboard.

Is tracking 30 different categories really necessary, or could you simplify without losing important insights? It's a common dilemma, even for the financially savvy.

A Harris poll shows that 74% of Americans say they have a monthly budget.

But for those of us who take our finances seriously, it's not just about having a budget—it's about striking the right balance between detail and manageability.

So, should you opt for a long list of categories or keep it short and sweet? Let's explore different approaches to determine how many categories you really need in your budget.

How many categories should you have in your budget?

If you're searching for the "correct" number of budget categories, we've got news: it doesn't exist. Your magic number is as individual as you are.

Some people thrive with just a handful of broad categories, while others prefer to break down every expense. Let's explore different approaches and find what works best for you.

Minimalist (3 categories)

One popular method, the 50/30/20 rule, divides your budget into three main categories:

  • Needs (50%): Essentials like housing, transportation, groceries, and utilities.
  • Wants (30%): Non-essential spending, such as dining out, entertainment, and hobbies.
  • Savings and Debt Repayment (20%): Setting aside money for savings, investments, or paying off debt.

Why choose this method?

This straightforward approach makes budgeting less overwhelming and easier to stick to. It's perfect for beginners or those who find detailed tracking daunting. The simplicity provides a clear, big-picture view of your finances without getting bogged down in minutiae.

The catch?

The lack of detailed insights might mean missing opportunities to identify and cut unnecessary expenses. For those with complex financial situations, this method might be too simplistic.

Moderate (10-15 categories)

A moderate approach expands on the minimalist model, breaking down the broad categories into more specific ones. The most common budget categories include:

  • Housing
  • Transportation
  • Groceries
  • Dining Out
  • Utilities
  • Insurance
  • Debt Repayment
  • Savings
  • Entertainment

Why choose this method?

This level of detail allows for more precise tracking and can help identify specific areas where you might be overspending.

It's a great middle ground for those who want more insight than the minimalist approach offers but don't need the granularity of a more comprehensive system.

It requires more time and effort than the minimalist approach. It may still not be detailed enough for those with very complex financial situations or highly specific financial goals.

It requires more time and effort than the minimalist approach. It may still not be detailed enough for those with very complex financial situations or highly specific financial goals.

Comprehensive (15+ Categories)

For any spreadsheet enthusiasts out there, this is a good match. This approach might involve 20 or more categories. For example:

  • Splitting "Housing" into Mortgage/Rent, Property Taxes, and Home Maintenance
  • Dividing "Transportation" into Car Payment, Gas, Maintenance, and Public Transit

Why choose this method?

This approach provides the most detailed view of your spending habits and allows for precise tracking of specific financial goals. It's ideal for those with complex financial situations or multiple income streams.

The catch?

It's time-consuming to set up and maintain, and can lead to "budget fatigue" if the process becomes too cumbersome. Consider whether this level of detail is truly necessary for your situation.

Factors influencing how many budget categories you need

When it comes to budgeting, there's no universal "right" number of categories. Your ideal setup depends on various aspects of your life, from your income sources to your future plans.

These factors don't just influence how many categories you need; they shape what those categories should be and how detailed they need to be.

Let's examine the key elements that will help you craft a budget that's perfectly tailored to your financial reality.

Income complexity

  • Single income stream: If you have a steady paycheck from a single job, you can likely get away with fewer budget categories. Focus on maximizing your savings and managing your spending efficiently. A simple budget structure will help you stay on track without overcomplicating things.
  • Multiple income streams: For those with income from various personal sources, like a side hustle, rental property, or part-time work, it's helpful to categorize each stream separately. This ensures you have a clear picture of where your money is coming from and how it’s contributing to your personal financial goals. Be sure to distinguish personal income from any business income or expenses, keeping personal finances organized and clear.
  • Investment income: If you have income from dividends, rental properties, or other investments, you’ll want dedicated budget categories for how you allocate that income. For example, you might reinvest dividends, use rental income for property expenses or maintenance, and allocate capital gains for larger personal or family goals. Categorizing how you spend or reinvest your investment income helps maintain clarity and ensure you're optimizing this passive income stream.

Lifestyle and life stage

  • Young professional: You might focus on categories like student loan repayment, building an emergency fund, and possibly saving for a down payment on a home.
  • Family with children: You'll likely need categories for childcare, education savings, and possibly separate accounts for each child's activities or allowances.
  • Near retirement: Your categories might shift towards healthcare costs, travel, and adjusting your investment mix for income generation.
  • Homeowner vs. renter: Homeowners will want separate categories for mortgage, property taxes, insurance, and maintenance. Renters might combine these into a single "Housing" category.

Financial goals and challenges

  • Debt payoff: If you're tackling multiple debts, separate categories for each can help you implement strategies like the debt avalanche or debt snowball method more effectively.
  • Saving for big purchases: Whether it's a home, a wedding, or a dream vacation, dedicated savings categories can help you visualize progress and stay motivated.
  • Building wealth: If you're focused on growing your net worth, you might want detailed investment categories broken down by account type (401(k), IRA, taxable accounts) or asset class.
  • Financial independence/early Retirement (FIRE): FIRE enthusiasts often benefit from very detailed expense tracking to optimize their savings rate. You might want categories for every non-essential expense to identify potential cuts.

Money management style

  • Data lovers: If you enjoy diving into spreadsheets and running analyses, a more detailed category system can provide rich insights.
  • Automation fans: If you prefer a set-it-and-forget-it approach, fewer, broader categories paired with automatic transfers might work better.
  • Impulse spenders: If you struggle with spontaneous purchases, detailed discretionary spending categories can help you identify and curb problem areas.
  • Value-based spenders: If you're intentional about aligning spending with your values, you might create categories based on life priorities (e.g., "Personal Growth," "Family Time," "Community Impact").

Remember, the perfect budget evolves with you. Don't be afraid to adjust your categories as your financial situation and goals change. The key is to find a system that provides the insights you need to make informed decisions without becoming a burden to maintain.

How to determine your categories

Creating the right mix of categories isn't about following a preset template—it's about crafting a system that captures your unique spending patterns and goals. Here's how to determine which categories will serve you best and how many you truly need:

1. Assess your spending habits

Start by analyzing your past 3-6 months of expenses. Look for patterns and outliers. Use your bank and credit card statements to categorize expenses, paying attention to monthly expenses versus one-time purchases.

Identify areas where you tend to overspend or underspend. Many budgeting apps can automatically categorize your spending, giving you a head start on this process.

2. Identify your priorities

Your budget should reflect your financial goals and values. List your short-term and long-term financial objectives. Consider which areas of spending bring you the most satisfaction or stress.

Determine which expenses are non-negotiable and which are flexible.

For example, if early retirement is a priority, you might need more detailed investment and savings categories. If you're focusing on debt repayment, separate categories for each debt could be beneficial.

3. Experiment and adjust as needed

Finding the right balance takes time.

Don't be afraid to iterate. Start with a moderate number of categories and adjust from there. Try different budgeting methods (like zero-based budgeting or the 50/30/20 rule) to see what feels most natural. Review your budget monthly and be willing to add, remove, or combine categories as needed.

Remember: The best budget is one you'll actually stick to. If you find yourself constantly overspending in certain categories or ignoring others, it's a sign that adjustments are needed.

Your budget should be a living document that evolves with your financial situation and goals.

Mistakes to avoid with budget categories

You've meticulously crafted your budget categories, feeling confident and in control. A month later, you're puzzling over a bloated "Miscellaneous" category and a tangle of misclassified expenses. Don't worry—even the pros can stumble here.

Here are some common mistakes when it comes to budget categories:

1. Overlapping categories

This occurs when expenses could logically fit into multiple categories, leading to confusion and inconsistent tracking.

Example: Having both "Dining Out" and "Entertainment" categories. A dinner with friends could fit in either, making it hard to consistently categorize expenses.

Solution: Create mutually exclusive categories or combine overlapping ones. In this case, you might have a "Social Spending" category that encompasses both dining out and entertainment with friends.

2. Overly specific categories

While detailed tracking can be insightful, overly specific categories can make budgeting tedious and unsustainable.

Example: Having separate categories for "Coffee Shops," "Work Lunches," and "Weekend Brunches" instead of a single "Dining Out" category.

Solution: Strike a balance between insight and manageability. Consider whether the extra detail truly adds value to your financial decision-making.

3. Missing essential categories

Forgetting to account for certain expenses can throw off your entire budget.

Common missing categories include:

  • Irregular expenses (annual subscriptions, car maintenance)
  • Savings for specific goals (vacation fund, home down payment)
  • Emergency fund contributions

Solution: Do a comprehensive review of your past year's expenses to catch any overlooked categories. Also, consider future expenses that may not have occurred in the past.

4. Inconsistent levels of detail

Having very detailed categories in some areas but vague ones in others can skew your financial picture.

Example: Having multiple specific investment categories but lumping all food expenses into a single "Food" category.

Solution: Aim for a consistent level of detail across your budget. Focus more granularity on areas where you want to influence behavior or track progress towards specific goals.

5. Rigid category types

As your financial situation evolves, your budget categories should too.

Example: Imagine you’ve had a "Gym Membership" category for years, but you haven't been to the gym in months because you've switched to working out at home.

Keeping that category in your budget out of habit can prevent you from allocating those funds to something more meaningful, like saving for a vacation or upgrading your home workout equipment.

Solution: Regularly review your budget categories (at least annually) to ensure they still reflect your current lifestyle and goals. This helps you stay flexible and make the most of your money as your priorities shift.

By avoiding these common pitfalls and following the steps to tailor your budget, you'll create a personalized system that provides valuable insights without becoming a burden.

Remember, the goal is to make your money work for you, not to become a slave to some arbitrary number of categories someone said you should have in your budget.

More from Creditnews